I can say 100% automated trading will win if we compare with manual Trading :) cause automated trading can Trade 24/5 meanwhile manual trading only trade a few time in a day! and as you can see most of signal provider using auto/EA to get thousand percent profit meanwhile manual trading like me only get a small profits. :)
and one more thing, if you have big money, you can use EA or automated trading to get big profit in market! but if you only have small money! my suggestion is stay away from EA, cause I have bad feeling with EA :) loland just FYI, EA or automated Trading are really good friends of brokerage! but not good friends with small trader like me :)